First of all, that is a beautiful 1/2 Taler. There is way to much meat left on that one for an AU55!In my opinion it's a AU58, but I guess it doesn't matter.Its a really detailed coin and I love the toning, it adds to it's beauty.
Quote from: coinsarefun on March 10, 2011, 10:35:19 PMFirst of all, that is a beautiful 1/2 Taler. There is way to much meat left on that one for an AU55!In my opinion it's a AU58, but I guess it doesn't matter.Its a really detailed coin and I love the toning, it adds to it's beauty.I feel it has been graded to low also.
Also, did you buy the coin raw and submit?Or did you buy it slabbed? If it was slabbed alreadymaybe you should crack it and re submit?Or at the very least leave it in the slab and submit witha minimum grade request.Just a thought.......it really is a nice one
Look it up and see how many are graded higher. If you have a registry it will give you the info.You may be able to make a better decision then. I would check the POP's at NGC as well.